When to Use Recruitment Agencies: Finding the Balance

​For recruitment and HR teams in law firms, timing is everything. When hiring for business services roles — from risk and compliance to knowledge — knowing when to bring in a recruitment agency can make the difference between a streamlined, successful hire and a frustrating, drawn-out process.

​

Let’s be honest: no one wants to be inundated with CVs thatalmosthit the mark, or worse, feel pressure to act on strong candidates too late in the process. But there’s a middle ground — a balance — where recruitment agencies, can add real value without disrupting your internal process.

​

It’s Not Just About Filling a Role

​

With years of experience supporting law firms ranging from elite global practices to boutique specialists, we’ve seen every kind of hiring challenge — sudden departures, team restructures, newly created roles, sensitive hires, and everything in between. The best recruitment partnerships go beyond simply sending CVs. Agencies like us work as an extension of your team, helping with:

​

• Market Insight & Salary Benchmarking

  Not sure where to pitch a new role? Wondering what the market appetite looks like for a particular skillset? We regularly benchmark salaries across top-tier, mid-sized, and boutique law firms, so we can provide up-to-date data on what similar firms are paying, what candidates are expecting, and where gaps might exist between internal expectations and market realities.

• Sounding Board for New Roles

  Even at the earliest stages, a good recruiter can help shape a new position. What should the title be? Would this attract a different profile if the reporting line changed? What are candidates in that space actually looking for?

• Candidate Screening & Fit

  Beyond the job spec, we look for culture fit, motivations, and long-term alignment. That’s especially important in law firms where team dynamics and discretion are crucial.

​

Use Us Early On In the Process

Some of the most successful placements come from clients who brought us inbeforethe job ad went live — giving us the context, the challenges, and the bigger picture. We could then identify and engage candidates who weren’t just qualified on paper but also aligned with the firm’s values, pace, and expectations.

Conversely, waiting until the final stages of a process to bring in a recruiter can limit options. You might get a fantastic CV... but if you're already deep into second-round interviews, there’s often little appetite to start over — no matter how impressive that candidate might be.

​

Choosing the Right Agency

​

This part matters. Not every agency understands the nuance of hiring into law firms. The pace, the structure, the expectations — it’s a very particular world. It’s important to partner with an agency that gets it.

​

We specialise in business services roles for law firms. Our network is deep, our understanding of firm cultures is nuanced, and we’re focused on quality over quantity. That typically means fewer CVs, but better matches. We also know when to push, when to pause, and when to advise — because recruitment isn’t just transactional, it’s strategic.

​

So, here's a few pointers on when we can help you get your best results:

​

• You’re shaping a new role and want market insight

• You need a strong shortlist fast — not just volume

• Internal resources are stretched

• The role is business-critical or confidential

• You want to sanity-check your salary and structure

​

But most importantly, use an agency that understands the legal sector and values long-term relationships.

​

If you’re hiring into risk & compliance, knowledge, or any other legal business services role — and want a recruitment partner who understands the inner workings of law firms, can speak the language of your hiring managers, and brings strategic insight, not just CVs — we’d love to have a conversation.

#LegalRecruitment

#LawFirmCareers

#RiskAndCompliance

#KnowledgeLawyers

#BusinessServices

#RecruitmentTips

#LegalHR

#HiringInsights

#PemburyLegal